Dog Man is a new 2025 animated superhero comedy film based on Dan Pilkey’s children’s graphic novel series from the same name. It serves as a spin-off and and story within a story of 2017’s Captain Underpants: The First Epic Movie. The film has an ensemble cast that includes Pete Davidson, Lil Rel Howery, Isla Fisher, Poppy Liu, Stephen Root, Billy Boyd, and Ricky Gervais. This is not only Universal’s second movie to come out this year, but it’s also the second one to have “Man” in the title. What’s more ironic is that I am giving them both the same score.

I can’t say I was looking forward to this at all. I knew nothing about it and nothing about interested me. I even had an invite to go see this early at a press screening, but tapped out the night before because of how tired I am. I felt like it wasn’t worth it. That says a lot when I saw every Universal movie that I have been invited to for the last year. I even saw Migration, which happened to be the movie that put me on the map for Universal’s screener list, so I am eternally grateful. This… was just not it. I am glad I didn’t sacrifice my sleep to see this.

With a 72% on Rotten Tomatoes and hearing the laughs surround me in the theater, I know this is going to be a hit. The film has a $40 million price tag attached to it, and I am already seeing where the film will make $30 million in its opening weekend. That’s great! Even if movies are not for me, I am glad that there are movies that help keep the theater business thriving. In recent years, it makes sense for studios to capitalize on family friendly movies as they almost never fail.

What I did like about the film is how it wears its heart on its sleeve through its humor and themes. The humor has a sarcastic tone that reminded me of DreamWorks’ original works with some strong scenes that stood out. I didn’t quite understand the sarcastic tone as it almost felt out of place, but there are some standout moments that did make me chuckle. The film even manages to have some meaningful character arcs with Petey (voiced by Pete Davison), having the strongest one that will connect with families.

Maybe I saw it in the wrong format, but I felt like my head went through blender after I saw it in Dolby. I know someone else who also watched it and enjoyed it in the same format. I think I am just more easily overstimulated. I don’t need loud noises and the plot changing every 5 minutes to be entertained. As someone who was not familiar with this property at all, I didn’t see the point in it at all. This was supposed to be a Captain Underpants spin-off, but you’d never know it. Considering it’s been 8 years since that movie, it’s hard to believe why no one thought it would be a good idea to have a connection to something that is far more popular.

The origin of how Dog Man becomes the titular character is not only dark, but it doesn’t make any sense. What we know about these characters before they have to become the same person is simply bizarre. So, they both died and became the same person? I know it’s a kid’s movie, but what a strange concept. They literally tie on the head of a dog of a human, but also give the character dog arms. This sounds like a concept better suited for a Tim Burton stop-motion picture. Once again, I am not familiar with the material its based off. Instead, it would have been better if there was no origin and we just saw this character as it was to begin with. Petey is already a cat. Why couldn’t we get the same thing with a dog? At least the dog could have a voice.

Since the film resolves around a character that mainly makes dog noises, it’s harder to relate to the character. Due to this, the film has Pete Davidson & Lil Rey Howery talking a LOT. I don’t mind Davidson and I really like Howery. It’s within the script and the direction that makes them be consistently loud and obnoxious for little to no reason. Sitting right next to a speaker throughout with everyone consistently yelling was not enjoyable.

The film also has multiple storylines going on at the same time. It feels like it’s changing every few minutes that it made me forget what happened moments earlier. Instead of trying to be exciting, it comes off boring and lifeless. I will say I like the animation, especially when it mimics its comic book style. When the plot changes every so often, why should I care though? I don’t even think the kid version of me would have enjoyed this.

I am not meaning to sound harsh. This is a film that has substantial potential. I love this type of humor. It reminds me of DreamWorks and Illumination’s earlier works. Similar to Despicable Me 4, I don’t need the plot to consistently change throughout. It feels like I got whiplash. It’s the equivalent of doom scrolling on TikTok. I think the film could have been better had it slow down in its pacing. The film is moving so quickly. By the time it gets to its third act, it stretches out for about 30 minutes to meet a reasonable runtime.

Overall, Dog Man will win over families and fans of the material, but this one is not for me. I don’t think I could recommend this to anyone who is neither familiar with the material nor anyone who doesn’t like genre. For me, there was plenty of missed potential that could have been better capitalized had it slow down the pacing and give the film more of a purpose. I don’t need to be overstimulated to be entertained. Maybe watching this in a quieter setting would make me appreciate it more.

VERDICT: 2/5 (Bad)