
The Girl with the Needle is a 2024 Danish historical psychological horror film directed by Magnus von Horn, from a screenplay written by von Horn & Line Langebek. The film was selected to compete for the Palme d’Or at the 77th Cannes Film Festival, named one of the top 5 international films of the year by the National Board of Review, and nominated for Best Foreign Language Film at the 82nd Golden Globe Awards and for Best International Feature Film at the 97th Academy Awards. The film takes place in 1919 where Karoline, played by Vic Carmen Sonne, who works as a wet nurse for a secretive adoption agency for disadvantaged mothers, grows suspicious of the woman who runs the operation.

I’ve been interested in the film for quite some time now, but a release date in the U.S., nor a digital screener, was available. Now that it became available on Mubi, I finally got around to seeing it. Since it’s now an Oscar nominee for the Best International Feature Film category, it felt like now was a perfect time to review it. Taking place 105 years prior to its release date, it’s fitting for the film to transport you back in time with it being in black-and-white. The opening credits are even in black-and-white (even if it goes on long enough to be a running gag).
This film truly blew me away. Many people are excited by the fact that The Substance is getting nominations at the Oscars, but I don’t think this one is getting the proper attention. To be fair, it’s been a lot harder to find and to watch. This story, though, is not for the faint of heart. It has imagery and story beats that will stay with you. For context, I am currently having to play Inside Out 2 in the background to having something more upbeat playing. If anything, I believe that goes to show how effective The Girl with the Needle is.

There’s quite a bit of story setup here that I clocked at around 40 minutes. For a 2-hour movie, that may not be for everyone. Some even may question if it was added just to fill up the runtime. To me, it adds so much development to the characters and to the story. Just when things get bad for Karoline, you think the major inciting incident is going to occur… and you’d be wrong. Everything she goes through gets worse and worse. At first, it seems like her problems of her own doing. Instead, her problems stem from the way people take advantage of her. It could speak on the way the horrors of war and societal issues were addressed at the time, but I’d go a step further to say that it still speaks on issues today.
From the way war veterans are treated when they come back home to tackling topics like abortion access and the morality around it is something that I believe viewers could strongly relate to. With a horror undertone, it brings shock, awe, and entertainment, but it will leave you with a dreadful feeling that we need do better for others and not do the things we believe will be for the best. The themes can get a little meddled at times. I wasn’t sure if the film was trying to condone abortion at times. I don’t believe that was the case. Then again, this is going to be a film that many people will get something different out of it.

One of the film’s strongest assets comes from the lead performance from actress Vic Carmen Sonne. Had I saw this sooner, she could have made possibly made it into my top 10 performances of the year. She is so earnest in her approach. You believe everything she is feeling. Every time things keeping worse for her, you feel even worse for her. It’s a performance that is 100% carried from start to finish. I can’t wait to see what she does next.
The film’s other strong assets stem from the cinematography and sound design. As mentioned, the film transports you back to its time, and that wouldn’t be possible without the film’s technical components. Not only does the film look like it was literally shot in 1919, but it has some beautiful imagery. It is consistently amazing to look at it, even in the film’s more disturbing scenes. The sound design is just as effective with bringing you back to its time. From the way the dialogue sounds to the eerie score, this offers something in film that is far too rare these days.

Overall, I can totally get on board with the praise The Girl with the Needle is getting, along with the awards recognition. The performances, cinematography, and sound design are all effective. The pacing may not be for everyone and the themes may get overlooked, but there is still something engaging and original here that’s worth exploring. I can’t see it winning Best International Feature Film at the Oscars, but the nomination warrants the film’s quality.
VERDICT: 4.5/5 (Amazing)












You must be logged in to post a comment.